by Beth Quick

“Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other … A threefold cord is not quickly broken.” (Ecclesiastes 4:9, 10a, 12b, NRSV)

I’ve been a vegetarian since I was a teenager, and a vegan for the past several years, but building community with other folks who are passionate about caring for animals is fairly new to me. A couple of years ago I connected with some regional groups of vegans, and I really enjoyed sharing space, virtual and physical, with others who were committed to justice for animals. What I didn’t find in those groups, though, were many connections with others who approached their animal advocacy from a faith perspective. I’ve always thought about my veganism and animal advocacy as grounded in my Christian discipleship. I think God entrusts humanity with caring for creation, and I think we’re inextricably linked with all God’s creatures. I think God’s vision for the world, God’s reign on earth, is a world where all can live into their full potential, and none of us can do that when we harm and exploit each other and the earth. I felt like my framing of my veganism as a matter of faith isolated me from other vegans.

Connecting with CreatureKind, then, has been a blessing to me: I am not alone! The opportunity to work as a CreatureKind fellow gives me even more opportunities to affirm that I am not alone in my faith-orientation to compassion for animals at all. My project focuses on working for legislative change for farmed animals within the polity of The United Methodist Church (UMC). I could try to achieve this polity change on my own. Strategically, though, I know that proposed changes to our advocacy statements in The UMC have a better chance of succeeding when they are supported by a group or coalition rather than just an individual. Part of my project, then, includes the work of coalition building.

In my initial proposal, I included coalition building as a secondary, supportive theme of the project. In the few weeks since the Fellowship began, I have moved the coalition-building topic to a primary position. I’m in the midst of realizing that my sense of isolation as a Christian vegan does not in fact mean that there are not other Christian animal advocates out there. Christians are already doing excellent, meaningful, transformative work (including all the good folx who have dreamed up and lived out the principles at CreatureKind, for example!).

I’ve been coming to terms with my privilege in assuming that I’m creating something that others aren’t already doing. This semester, my first semester of a PhD program at Drew Theological School, one of my courses focus on feminist theory. Our first readings in the class focused on raising awareness of how white women feminists have written a “history of feminism” that assumes that the feminism of white women in the United States is first, original, and setting the standard for the work of dismantling patriarchy and oppression of women. In reality, though, women of color and women around the world have long been engaged in articulating feminist aims and dismantling oppressive structures. Feminist theory involves critiquing and correcting the dominant (white) narrative’s oversight and suppression of the excellent work being done by black, Asian, and Latinx women, by indigenous women, and by women around the globe. As I start the work of coalition building for my project, I wonder what excellent work people are already doing that I’m not seeing because of my place of privilege as a white middle-class woman from the United States.

Already, I’m finding delight in new connections with co-laborers for farm animals that are popping up nearly faster than I can keep up with them. Perhaps I’ll be bringing some people together for new, specific conversations. Yet, this group will be made of workers with existing wisdom, experience, and connections from which I can learn, people who will help shape me, even as I seek to shape The UMC’s view of animals. I’m thankful that I am not alone in my work. Instead, I’m a strand in a many-folded cord that’s being woven to work for God’s creatures, human and nonhuman alike.

Beth Quick (she/her/hers) is a PhD student of Drew Theological Seminary in Religion and Society with a focus on ecology and animal ethics. Beth currently resides in Madison, NJ and is pursuing work in various levels of the United Methodist Church to craft legislation and polity in defense of farmed animals in her role as a CreatureKind Fellow. Beth blogs and posts ministry resources including sermons and sung communion liturgies at www.bethquick.com. She published Singing at the Table, a collection of sung communion liturgies, in the summer of 2020.

by David Clough

Why might Christians consider going vegan? There are four reasons that overlap with the reasons anyone else might give: concern for the environment, concern for animals, concern for human welfare, and the desire to adopt a more healthy diet. In addition, Christians might be inspired by long religious traditions of fasting from meat and other animal products. I’ll consider these reasons in turn below. Let’s start, though, with something more fundamental: why a Christian understanding of God and the world might provide specific motivation for going vegan.

Christians believe in that everything in the universe owes its existence to God. That’s what monotheism means: the God Christians worship is not just their God, or even the God of all humans, but the God of all creatures. Biblical texts celebrate the God who made all creatures and declared them good (Genesis 1), who made a world in which every creature has its own place (Psalm 104), who has compassion on and provides for every living thing (Psalm 145), and who in Jesus Christ acts to release the whole of creation from its groaning bondage (Romans 8) and to gather up and make peace between all things in heaven and earth (Colossians 1.20; Ephesians 1.10). Jesus reassured his followers by reminding them that not a single sparrow is forgotten in God’s sight (Luke 12.6). John describes God’s son coming to the earth because of God’s love for the world (John 3.16). God’s delight in and care for all God’s creatures means Christians have reason to delight in and care for them too, especially as humans are called to be images of God. Seeing the whole world as charged with God’s grandeur, as the poet Gerard Manley Hopkins put it, is a fundamental aspect of a Christian vision of the world.

So Christians recognize the universe and all creatures in it as belonging to God, beloved by God, and cared for by God. Why might that make a difference for how they eat? Let’s return to the five reasons I noted above.

First, Christians might move towards a vegan diet in order to care for God's creation, the environment. Greenhouse gas emissions from a huge expansion in raising livestock is a significant cause of the climate catastrophe we are bringing about, which will have a devastating impact on humans and other animals. Reducing consumption of animal products is one of the quickest ways to reduce our carbon footprint. Industrial animal agriculture causes local environmental problems, too. Big intensive pig farms with their huge lagoons of excrement are horrible to live nearby, and so are disproportionately likely to be placed near poor communities, making their lives miserable.

Second, Christians might become vegan in order to enable fellow creatures to flourish, to praise God each in their particular way. The vast majority of farmed animals are raised in industrial systems that subject them to unnecessary suffering and impoverished lives in which they cannot thrive and glorify God. Most fish now come from intensive farmed environments, or if wild-caught, are subjected to unsustainable fishing practices and long drawn-out deaths. The large-scale production of dairy and eggs entails killing male animals surplus to requirements and female animals once their productivity declines. These are powerful reasons for adopting a vegan diet, rather than just a vegetarian one. Current production levels of animals for consumption inhibit the flourishing of wild animals as well as domesticated animals. By 2000, the biomass of domesticated animals exceeded that of all wild land mammals by 24 times. The biomass of domesticated chickens alone is nearly three times that of all wild birds. These shocking statistics show that humans are monopolizing the productive capacity of the earth in a way that leaves very little space for wild animals at all, which is part of what is driving their mass extinction.

Third, Christians might shift to a vegan diet in order to save the lives of fellow human creatures. The livestock industry threatens human food and water security, and those already suffering from deprivation are at greatest risk. Christians are explicitly directed to care for those with the greatest needs and the least resources. Currently, over a third of global cereal output goes to farmed animals and humans eating the animals receive only 8% of the calories that would be available if humans ate the cereals directly. Animal agriculture is also a very significant consumer of scarce global water supplies: producing 1 kg of beef requires 10 to 20 times the water required by producing the same calories from plant-based sources. While a vegan diet is not immediately practical in every part of the world (for Siberian pastoralists reliant on reindeer herds, for example), it is very clear that the global human population, as well as animals and the environment, would benefit from a transition towards using plant-based foods wherever possible.

Fourth, Christians might adopt a vegan diet in order to sustain the health and well-being of their families, friends, neighbours, and wider society. The unprecedentedly high levels of meat and other animal products consumed in developed nations directly damages human health (increased incidence of heart disease, cancer, type 2 diabetes, and strokes). In addition, intensive farming practices contribute to both the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains and the risk of pandemics from zoonotic diseases such as swine and bird flu.

Finally, many Christians will be inspired by the long Christian traditions of fasting from meat and other animal products, on Fridays, during Lent, and at other times. Many Coptic Christians today observe fasts imposing a vegan diet for two-thirds of the year. The practice of not eating animal products can be understood as part of a penitential practice that redirects one’s focus away from selfish pleasure and towards God. Such traditions remind Christians of the limits that come with recognizing God as creator: animals belong to God, so humans must treat them with respect and can’t do whatever we want with them.

Christians often note arguments against vegetarianism or veganism, but these concerns do not end the conversation. Genesis 1 identifies human beings as uniquely images of God and grants them dominion over other animals, but the end of the chapter prescribes a vegan diet for humans, so this original dominion does not include permission to kill animals for food. In Genesis 9, following the flood, God allows humans to kill animals for food, but this does not justify modern patterns of raising animals in industrial systems in ways that are so clearly damaging for humans, animals, and the wider environment. Gospel accounts record Jesus as eating fish and offering fish to others (although, interestingly, he is not recorded as eating mammals or poultry), but whatever his practice, it does not justify eating the products of modern industrial animal agriculture. Some of these concerns suggest that would be implausible to claim that a vegan diet should be an absolute obligation for all Christians. They do not show that it is inappropriate to adopt a vegan diet as a response to the broad concerns noted above that relate to the modern context of raising animals for food where there are readily available alternative sources of nutrition.

It is important to note that veganism in a Christian context should never be presented as a moral utopia. Christians recognize a brokenness in our relationships with fellow creatures which cannot be overcome by adopting a particular dietary practice or by any other effort we can make. Vegan Christians should not make claims to moral superiority: they are sinners like everyone else. They are simply seeking to act as responsibly as they can in this aspect of the choices they make about what to eat. They should hope to learn from fellow Christians about better ways of living in other areas of their lives, just as they may hope that fellow Christians may be open to learning from their practice.

Concern for fellow humans, fellow animal creatures, and the environment are obligations for Christians, and so the impacts of modern animal agriculture should trouble all Christians. It’s important to realize that farmers are not the villains here: farmers are often pressured into systems of poor farmed animal welfare because of the popular desire for cheap animal products and the retailers' power to determine pricing for their own advantage. A Christian vision of delighting in God’s world and living responsibly among the fellow creatures God loves will be an inspiration to many Christians to adopt a vegan diet.

This article was originally posted on The Vegan Society’s website.